READING LEVEL 6.7 AR POINTS: 3.0


Why Not, Lafayette? by Jean Fritz (1999; 2001 ed.) 84 pages.

‘Why not?’ was Lafayette’s motto. He was tired of everyone saying no. His father had died while fighting in a war and, at age two, his mom left for Paris, leaving him with his grandparents to raise. After marrying and his second child born, he snuck away to America to help her fight for her independence.

He became like a son to George Washington and fought side by side with him. They were inseparable. Lafayette even named his son after him, George Washington de Lafayette.

Marie Joseph Paul Yves Roch Gilbert du Motier, Marquis de Lafayette, otherwise known simply as Lafayette, or sometimes Gilbert, was a Frenchman from Paris. He absolutely loved America and its independence and fought all his life to bring it to France. He stood against Napoleon Bonaparte, who wanted to conquer and rule all of Europe. He even spent many years in a German prison, when he was trying to escape a Revolution when the liberties took over and were beheading all the aristocrats. Unfortunately, Marquis de Lafayette was born into the aristocrats, but, he did not believe in the title and never allowed anyone in France to call him Marquis. Still, they considered him an aristocrat.

He was well-known and loved by the Americans and had travelled back and forth over the years. On his final trip over to the U.S., Americans welcomed him like a king. And when he left he took a crate full of American soil to cover his grave when he died. He took back so many other things as well, so much so that he had to use a second vessel just to carry his newly acquired American belongings, which included many animals.

This was a great and interesting little chapter book story for young readers. I had no idea who Lafayette was and now am anxious to learn more about him. Fayetteville, North Carolina, was named after him. Now, there are at least half a dozen towns called Fayetteville throughout the U.S. named after our America loving Frenchman. ( )

This chapter book describes the life of Lafayette and how he got involved as a major-general in the American Revolutionary War despite being from French nobility. It is engaging so far and describes how lost LaFayette felt as a young man in the predetermined role that he inherited. This book would be best for 3rd grade and up, as it is a chapter book. Some of the concepts may be tricky for a child who is just learning to read chapter books to understand.

Do you remember who Marie-Joseph Paul Yves Roch Gilbert du Motier was? He is very famous in American history, but you probably know him better as the Marquis de Lafayette, or, as he preferred to be called, just Lafayette, who was born Sept. 6, 1757. His father died before he was two years old and his mother and grandfather died when he was twelve, leaving him to inherit their fortune under the guardianship of his great-grandfather. At fourteen years old, he joined the French Military and, at age sixteen, married Marie Adrienne Francoise de Noailles, whose family was related to King Louis XVI. At nineteen, against the wishes of his great-grandfather, his father-in-law, and the King, he purchased a ship and persuaded several French officers to accompany him to fight in the American Revolution.

And, the rest, as they say, is history. Colonial General George Washington appointed Lafayette a major general. Wounded at Brandywine, the young Frenchman endured the freezing winter at Valley Forge, and then saw action at Barren Hill and Rhode Island. Returning to France for as time, he, along with Ben Franklin, was able to secure troops and supplies from the French government for the American cause which helped to force Cornwallis to surrender at Yorktown. By then Lafayette was again in America and present for the surrender. Back in France, Lafayette upheld the ideals of liberty all through the French Revolution, the Reign of Terror, and the rule of Napoleon, though he spent five years in an Austrian prison. Following his release, in 1824, President James Monroe invited Lafayette to the United States as the "nation's guest,” and during the trip, he visited all twenty-four states.

Jean Fritz is a wonderful author. We have read and liked many of her biographies for children, such as George Washington's Breakfast; And Then What Happened, Paul Revere?; Where Was Patrick Henry on the 29th of May?; Will You Sign Here, John Hancock?; Just A Few Words, Mr. Lincoln; The Double Life of Pocahontas; and Harriet Beecher Stow and the Beecher Preachers. We have also enjoyed a few of her young people’s novels, such as Early Thunder; The Cabin Faced West; and Brady. Some parents might want to know that George Washington is quoted as having called the hapless General Charles Lee a “d*** poltroon.” It is said that Lafayette had never heard Washington swear before, “but obviously he could.” Lafayette was truly a remarkable character in history. It is no wonder that General John J. Pershing is reported to have said when he and his armies landed in France during World War I to help the French against the attacks of Kaiser Bill’s Germany and its allies, “Lafayette, we are here.” ( )