Afbeelding van de auteur.
3 Werken 185 Leden 5 Besprekingen

Over de Auteur

Bevat de naam: Daniel Beer

Werken van Daniel Beer

Tagged

Algemene kennis

Leden

Besprekingen

I literally had never conceived of how the banished arrived in Siberia, I suppose I assume by train. Of course they walked, fettered, sometimes for two years through the worst of seasons before they could even begin their sentences.

The individual chapters read as lectures, without much narrative glue but the chapters together do illustrate the terrible tale. So many endless, thwarted upstarts and revolutionaries.
 
Gemarkeerd
kcshankd | 4 andere besprekingen | May 26, 2023 |
Didn't actually finish it. Excellent account of Russian punishment... Siberian and otherwise. Also picked up lots of Russian history along the way.
 
Gemarkeerd
apende | 4 andere besprekingen | Jul 12, 2022 |
I came across this book while of all things reading a biography of Friedrich Nietzsche. There was reference to Dostoevsky's book of fiction/non-fiction of the similar title. So it peaked my curiosity and I thought I would give it a go.

The book covers roughly 100 years of the Czarist regimes efforts to deport to and also populate the remote and forbidding recesses of the vast Siberian expanse of Asia. Starting around the Decembrist uprising to the full Bolshevik revolution of 1917. A grim story of suffering and anguish for so many that suffered the fate of banishment and penal servitude. This encompassed a variety of offenders from street criminals and murderers to political dissidents and revolutionaries. Many paid with their lives but even more astonishingly many more survived. Yet few ever made it back to European Russia.

The many accounts and ordeals of these unfortunates play out in a never ending procession leading at some point to almost monotony. And the end result was that despite their oppression the tide eventually turned as the aristocracy was itself obliterated. Lesson learned. Or was it, as this was simply replaced with the intensified version of the Soviet answer to opposition on an even greater scale.
… (meer)
 
Gemarkeerd
knightlight777 | 4 andere besprekingen | Jun 30, 2019 |
The Russian "Exile System" during the 19th century was a fraction of the size of the more famous Gulag system under the Soviets in th 20th. They were not exactly the same but both systems solved two problems: how to deal with "sedition" (political agitators) and criminals; and how to obtain labor for resource extraction (mines and lumber). For the Tsar's in the early 19th century the solution was simple and obvious - send the rabble to Siberia to be forgotten. It worked for a while but by the 1860s the contradictions and public outrage began to undermine its legitimacy. What started as a good idea lasted far longer than it should have at huge human cost and arguably was an accelerant of the Russian Revolution.

Many famous books have been written by Exiles in the 19th century including Dostoevsky's The House of the Dead (1860). Lenin spent three years in an exile camp. Checkhov wrote a series of articles later published as a book Sakhalin Island. The thread of exile runs long and deep in Russian history.

What this history teaches is how a fundamentally inhumane system that almost everyone agrees is wrong can still become self-reinforcing and impossible to dismantle for economic and political reasons, a problem that continues to this day in many forms and places. A modern example of this is described in the book Evicted: Poverty and Profit in the American City.
… (meer)
 
Gemarkeerd
Stbalbach | 4 andere besprekingen | Feb 6, 2017 |

Lijsten

Prijzen

Misschien vindt je deze ook leuk

Statistieken

Werken
3
Leden
185
Populariteit
#117,260
Waardering
3.9
Besprekingen
5
ISBNs
15
Talen
4

Tabellen & Grafieken