Tom Chaffin

For a book that's supposed to be about two men's "brotherhood," there turns out not to be too much of that.

Sure, Jefferson and Lafayette worked together some in Paris and communicated over decades. But I didn't get the sense that they were as close as, say, Jefferson and John Adams (not withstanding their falling out for some years). They hardly saw each other on American soil and for the years they were both in France, there didn't seem to be a great deal of time spent with each other. No doubt they had great respect and admiration for each other, but I never got the feeling like they were "brothers."

I far more enjoyed the first third of the book—the part that takes place in America during the Revolution. Once Jefferson arrives in France, things bogged down quite a bit for me. This is more a reflection of my ignorance of French pronunciation and geography than that of the author's skill and research.

I did like the book's frequent breaks and relatively small chapters. As unacademic as that is, the writing was not. The style was not much to my liking. And don't get me started on the author's overuse of parenthetical phrases.

That said, "Revolutionary Brothers" does offer some excellent insight into the minds of both protagonists, much of which I'd not encountered before.… (meer)

I should perhaps preface my review by saying I am not a civil war buff. My interest in war history is minimal, but I'm trying to expand my horizons for 2013 and picked this book up when my mom recommended it. I struggled in places where I needed some more background on the war and its players. As xenchu wrote, it's not a scholarly work, which I very much benefitted from. It is a quite factual book. Unfortunately, the facts around the Hunley and its submarine predecessors are few. Not being a (civil war) history buff, I found myself extremely frustrated by how often there were no source documents or accounts. I felt like I was reading a lot of "well this is what might have happened... or it could have been this." There were some lovely turns of phrase (porpoiselike aplomb!), I'd certainly recommend this to anyone who enjoys reading about the civil war or maritime history.… (meer)