Rafal Gerszak

This photo journal of a foreigner in Afghanistan, Rafal Gerszak, covers both military and civilian persepective. The photographer is a Polish-Canadian who spent time as a youth in a refugee camp. He embeds with American forces in the first part of the book, but later comes back to the country on his own to witness Afghan civilian life. Some of it takes your breathe away. The volunteer doctor, the soldier who appears on the cover, the stoic mother guarding her dying child. We also get a bit of insight into the photographer's (rather than reporter) take on life, reflected best by the composition of the book.… (meer)

Part journal, part commentary, this 100+ page photo diary shows a non-heroic side to the war in Afghanistan. There is no titillation or melodrama in the words and photos showing the disconnect between modernity (bullet-proof tanks) and traditional practices (camels), between peace (praying to Allah) and war (loading an injured victim in to a helicopter). Despite the whimsical handwriting font and the picture book format, the content is ill-suited for young readers, as topics including suicide, death, loss of limb, bombs, post-traumatic stress, and shooting are mentioned matter-of-factly. Still, the second half of the story, focusing on civilian life, brings unexpected moments -- Afghans riding amusement park rides, diving into swimming pools, and piloting paddle boats. Few teens have imagined that there is world beyond the military story, a world of Coke cans, a golf course, a zoo featuring Afghanistan's only pig, and dice games. Photos of men are far more prevalent than those of women (due to Afghan societal mores). Although captions on the photos would be a welcome addition, this honest, balanced photomemoir has an urgently-needed place in teen collections. The author/photographer's own youth was spent in part in refugee camps. Highly recommended. (228)… (meer)

5 STARS
This is not my typical type of book. Can't say I loved it but I do understand a little bit more about Afganistan and it's people. I wish their was no need for any war.
Rafel Gerszak spent a year enbedded with American troups. He saw and photographed the war. Then later he went back to Afganistan on his own to see how the life was during war and what they were like.
This book was filled with pictures he took. Also had his journal and what was going on. plus facts about the people,politics.
He showed the struggle the people with injuries from war. Doctors treating people without the drugs and supplies we take for granted. Showed how the women are and told more because its hard to get photographs of women. Showed some changes, somethings stay the same.
Told how after a year enbedded than comming back to see the everyday life than going back with same American troups how much he had changed too.
I was given an ebook of this book so it was a little hard sometimes to see all I wanted to see. These photos moved me and make me appreciate the freedoms that I and my girls have. Hard to see the suffering but it's good that we know the cost of wars and freedoms.… (meer)