Afbeelding van de auteur.

Over de Auteur

Gregg Herken is Historian and Curator at the Space History Department of the National Air and Space Museum, Smithsonian Institution

Bevat de naam: Gregg F. Herken

Fotografie: Photo courtesy of Gregg Herken

Werken van Gregg Herken

Gerelateerde werken

Tagged

Algemene kennis

Leden

Besprekingen

Brotherhood of the Bomb is an outstanding book on many of the individuals responsible during the Manhattan Project for the creation of the first atomic bomb and later the hydrogen bomb as well as the endless debates on the use of atomic energy and the desire to increase or eliminate testing and the decision to strip Robert Oppenheimer of his security clearance.

Many of the people in the book are well known to us who have read on the scientific community of the bomb at the time. The book revolves around Robert Oppenheimer, Ernest O. Lawrence, General Leslie R. Groves, Edward Teller, and later after the development of the bomb, Lewis Strauss, the driving force behind the hearing to strip Robert Oppenheimer of his security clearance.

The book discusses the development and use of the atomic bomb and, later, the development of the hydrogen bomb, the essence of the book is more about the personal relationships, dynamics, and motivations of this brotherhood of the bomb. I strongly recommend this book and give it a strong 4-star rating. If you are looking for a book more closely aligned query the development of the bomb I recommend Richard Rhodes, The Making of the Atomic Bomb or Kai Bird's American Prometheus, but for a book about the personal dynamics of these individuals this is the book to read.
… (meer)
 
Gemarkeerd
dsha67 | 2 andere besprekingen | Nov 6, 2023 |
Brilliant history of the political elite during the Cold War, centered on the Georgetown Set. I knew a few of these people in their later years. They put the current political class to shame.
 
Gemarkeerd
JamesSchumaker | 1 andere bespreking | Jul 10, 2021 |
This book is a reminder that there once was a Washington DC smaller in style and intellectually vibrant with a mix of social grace and an understanding of the difference between debate, differing views and professional grace. The author Gregg Herken delves into the lifestyle of a Georgetown filled with political achievers, reporters and a cadre of political professionals. The energy of a time when dinner and drinks made-up a platform for lively discussion and the exchange of ideas. Based largely on the social circle and professional interchange of two brothers -- Joe and Stewart Alsop accomplished writers, columnists and political pundits -- this clique of individuals steered the country in a direction of policy decisions. As stated in the inside cover of this interesting book "this was a smaller, cozier Washington … where president's made foreign policy in consultation with reporters and professors over martinis and hors d'oeuvres". Reporters favored politicians with support for policy with the exchange of favored insider information. But with all periods of change, change would not leave this "world" alone either. There are markers on the timeline; events that change direction and attitudes. This was a time of the Kennedy assassinations, civil rights, changing moralities, Vietnam and Watergate. Through it all, however, one thing stands-out in this book -- perhaps something that has been lost just like the social Georgetown dinner party -- an ability to disagree and yet, still have a nice dinner.… (meer)
 
Gemarkeerd
MikeBiever | 1 andere bespreking | Aug 3, 2018 |
Herken's volume has both strengths and weaknesses. He is better on drawing out the drama in developing an ultimate weapon, the complexity of forces between the government, academia, the individual characteristics of the primary initiators, and the relationships between the creators. He seems to reliably chronicle the relationship between the tangled lives of the creators. On the other hand, he does not seem able to tease out the seemingly contradictory position that leftists created the most destructive weapon in humankind.

How did Oppenheimer become a leftist? Herken chronicles his activities, he demonstrates the disagreements among his staff, the more radical nature of his brother's leftism, but Herken leaves unexplained Oppenheimer's biographical details that may indicate why the Oppenheimer's developed confirmed radical notions. According to Herken, Oppenheimer experienced pangs of conscience following the Hiroshima and Nagasaki blasts, but Oppenheimer had already associated with, and attended Communist Party functions. Herken fails to explain the tangled relationship between the pre-blast Oppenheimer and his subsequent brand of leftist pacifism. And, Oppenheimer's brother Frank early on was a confirmed radical but we do not find out what occurred in the Oppenheimer family home that resulted in both Robert's and Frank's variety of leftism. The most we left with are inadequate explanations arising from the Oppenheimer's younger development as a product of the Ethical culture in their home and adult friendships with Communist sympathizers, particularly with Haakon Chevalier.

The strongest evidence against Oppenheimer, which led to the decision to deny him a security clearance, is the "Chevalier incident." Chevalier seems to have done no more than approach Oppenheimer on the behalf of sympathizers against the Franco regime in Spain. Although Oppenheimer associated with and knew Communists he did little more than discuss, or lend a sympathetic ear to those inclined to oppose Fascism during the pre-War period. Herken fails to successfully elucidate these crucial aspects of Oppenheimer's life work and political development. It reads rather dryly as a recitation of facts as opposed to a clearly written exposition of Oppenheimer, Lawrence, and Teller.
… (meer)
 
Gemarkeerd
gmicksmith | 2 andere besprekingen | Jun 14, 2009 |

Prijzen

Misschien vindt je deze ook leuk

Gerelateerde auteurs

Statistieken

Werken
5
Ook door
2
Leden
403
Populariteit
#60,270
Waardering
½ 3.6
Besprekingen
5
ISBNs
25

Tabellen & Grafieken