Afbeelding van de auteur.

T. C. McCarthy

Auteur van Germline

11+ Werken 360 Leden 27 Besprekingen

Over de Auteur

Bevat de naam: T.C. McCarthy

Reeksen

Werken van T. C. McCarthy

Germline (2011) 197 exemplaren
Exogene (2012) 83 exemplaren
Chimera (2012) 52 exemplaren
Tyger Burning (2019) 11 exemplaren
Tyger Bright (2021) 6 exemplaren
Sunshine (Subterrene) (2012) 3 exemplaren
The Legionnaires 3 exemplaren
Somewhere it Snows (2012) 2 exemplaren
A People's Army (2012) 1 exemplaar
Podziemna wojna Genoboty (2014) 1 exemplaar

Gerelateerde werken

War Stories: New Military Science Fiction (2014) — Medewerker — 72 exemplaren
Operation Arcana (2015) — Medewerker — 68 exemplaren
Onward, Drake! (2015) — Medewerker — 39 exemplaren
Sword & Planet (2021) — Medewerker — 21 exemplaren
Free Short Stories 2013 (2013) — Medewerker — 12 exemplaren
2013 Campbellian Pre-Reading Anthology (2013) — Medewerker — 7 exemplaren

Tagged

Algemene kennis

Gangbare naam
McCarthy, T. C.
Geslacht
male

Leden

Besprekingen

10 word review: excellent capstone to McCarthy's brutal & soul crushing tales of war
 
Gemarkeerd
lmorganjr | Dec 21, 2020 |
10 word review: intense PTSD-laden yet touching story of war, camaraderie, and luck
 
Gemarkeerd
lmorganjr | 18 andere besprekingen | Dec 21, 2020 |
10 word review: a thrilling second chapter; a further discourse on faith & death
 
Gemarkeerd
lmorganjr | 5 andere besprekingen | Dec 21, 2020 |
Quote:
"I'm not who I used to be." Maung paused. Even with all the data and processing power he had, trying to express feelings left him frustrated. "I'm not a killer anymore."


Review:
I unfortunately discontinued reading this at 75%. I tried really, really hard, but I found that I just couldn't get past core aspects of the book. And those were making me dread getting back to reading the book every time I put it down.

The biggest problem I had was that Tyger Burning was very racist against the Chinese and Burmese. And they aren't so great against other Asians, either. I made all sorts of excuses throughout. "It makes sense in the context of the book!", "They just lost a war, this is the same generation that lost their lives!" and more. However, it was just way above what was needed to get the point across. It was constant, every couple pages, and it just never got any better. Maybe it got better at the end, I just couldn't make it there.

Then all of this racism took time away from the actual plot. So much time is spent on the racism that wasn't spent on developing the plot or the world. So I felt barely anything happened. There were so many ideas that got introduced and then discarded in order to shit on the main character's nationality some more in the next page. It was so frustrating.

The main character, Muang, was another source of frustration for me. This feels like it is nitpicking, but I just couldn't get over it the entire book. Muang is supposed to be stupid. The Chinese took part of his brain and replaced it with computer stuff. When the computer is off, which is when he isn't in danger, he is supposed to be stupid since he is literally missing part of his brain. Only he isn't. He is clumsy, but he isn't stupid in my opinion. Those aren't the same thing. I believe it is supposed to be shown through all the questions he asks, but that was basically just the bare minimum he needed to have asked to understand his situation he found himself in.

Also, I found the relationship distatestful. It develops in the middle of the book. It was clear very early on that she was going to be the love interest but it never truly develops. But the relationship goes from completely not interested, to separated and obsessed (how??) to "let's fuck". Hmm. And then Muang starts deciding things for the love interest without asking her. Major things.

That last thing, the main character making major life decisions for the love character without asking, all because he is obsessed with her? That is what decided my decision to discontinue reading this. I couldn't make excuses any longer. Especially when I sat down and very little interesting happened. Lots of interesting things were introduced, but they never seemed to stay around.

I received this book from Edelweiss in exchange for an honest review. Thank you to T.C. McCarthy, Baen, and Edelweiss for providing the opportunity to review this copy.
… (meer)
 
Gemarkeerd
keikii | Jan 23, 2020 |

Lijsten

Prijzen

Misschien vindt je deze ook leuk

Gerelateerde auteurs

Statistieken

Werken
11
Ook door
6
Leden
360
Populariteit
#66,630
Waardering
½ 3.5
Besprekingen
27
ISBNs
43
Talen
2

Tabellen & Grafieken