Afbeelding van de auteur.

John Maynard Smith (1920–2004)

Auteur van The Theory of Evolution

27+ Werken 1,158 Leden 6 Besprekingen Favoriet van 5 leden

Over de Auteur

Werken van John Maynard Smith

Gerelateerde werken

The Oxford Book of Modern Science Writing (2008) — Medewerker — 803 exemplaren
Daedalus, Spring 1965: Utopia (1965) — Medewerker — 7 exemplaren
New Scientist, 9 November 1961 (1961) — Medewerker — 1 exemplaar

Tagged

Algemene kennis

Leden

Besprekingen

Don't be fooled by the small size of this book; it is not a book for a casual reader. If you are not familiar with evolutionary genetics, you may find the amount of jargon offputting. Do you know what cytoplasmic streaming is? Then you will find it readable. The author never bothers to define any terms, but sprinkles them freely throughout his work. This is okay if you are aiming a book at a scientific audience, but this is aimed at a general audience, or at least the author thinks it is. In addition, it probably isn't the best work to choose, since it was written nearly 20 years ago, and EvoDevo has moved along a lot since that time. The final chapter was absolutely out of the realm of science, as he speculated that your political views determined which view of evolutionary development you took; as he became more conservative, his views moved toward that of a reductionist. There may be some truth to that, but I think there are way to many people on the side of genetic control for a group of specialists mostly dominated by political liberals for this to be the case. In any case, it was strictly anecdotal, and should have been left out of the book, since it appeared it might have been included for the purpose of making a "point" about people who were politically out of tune with him. This is not the place for that, and without more solid eidence than, oh, I know some people, and this is my own views, this should not have been included at all. Overall, a bit of a disappointment, but then, it is quite out of date, so maybe I shouldn't have expected much.… (meer)
 
Gemarkeerd
Devil_llama | May 29, 2016 |
Some interesting insights, neatly put. For example, "Evolution tends to adapt the nature of animals and plants to their environments. In history, man has adapted his environment to his nature". Contrast this with the Darwin-centric view of (for example) Dawkins. He also makes the point that humans have for a considerable time, sought (and in many cases succeeded, even without today's technologies), to 'direct the evolution of their domestic animals and plants'.
 
Gemarkeerd
NaggedMan | Jan 26, 2015 |
gonna read it for presenting that leaflet for the "special topics in physics"...all the ideas and concepts of it seem confusing and intresting...:)
 
Gemarkeerd
shahabodin | Feb 5, 2009 |
When you read a books of previously published essays you have to expect repetition, and lack of continuity. Repitition of content is one thing. Smith seems to have reused whole paragraphs and groups of paragraphs in different essays. At least once I checked that I didn't have a bad copy with the same pages bound in twice.

You also expect the editors to give you at least a few hints as to the context of the essays, if that is important to reading them. Several of these essays are book reviews, but the book reviewed is not named in the chapter, just in the bibliographic information at the back of the book. The beginning of the first chapter that is a book review beginns with 'This book...' The book reviewed, that is, NOT obvious in this context.

In the end, I think I learned something from reading this, but I'm not eager to read another book by him, unless there is some indication that it has been better edited before publishing.
… (meer)
½
 
Gemarkeerd
MarthaJeanne | 1 andere bespreking | Nov 2, 2008 |

Lijsten

Misschien vindt je deze ook leuk

Gerelateerde auteurs

Statistieken

Werken
27
Ook door
3
Leden
1,158
Populariteit
#22,187
Waardering
4.0
Besprekingen
6
ISBNs
60
Talen
6
Favoriet
5

Tabellen & Grafieken