| Titels | Volgorde |
| After the Night door Linda Howard | Most Luscious Love Story - Honorable Mention, 1997 |
| Als een vlinder in de zon door Catherine Anderson | Most-Hanky Read - Honorable Mention, 1997 |
| Always to Remember door Lorraine Heath | Most-Hanky Read - Honorable Mention, 1997 |
| Anyone But You door Jennifer Crusie | Favorite Romance of the Year - Honorable Mention, 1997 |
| Breath of Magic door Teresa Medeiros | Favorite Road Romance - Honorable Mention, 1997 |
| Brides of Prairie Gold door Maggie Osborne | Favorite Road Romance, 1997 |
| Dance door Judy Cuevas | Most Luscious Love Story - Honorable Mention, 1997 |
| Daring to Dream door Nora Roberts | Favorite Road Romance - Honorable Mention, 1997 |
| High Energy door Dara Joy | Most Luscious Love Story - Honorable Mention, 1997 |
| Ik neem je mee door Jennifer Crusie | Feistiest Heroine - Honorable Mention, 1997 |
| Jackson Rule door Sharon Sala | Most Tortured Hero, 1997 |
| Kiss an Angel door Susan Elizabeth Phillips | Favorite Romance of the Year - Honorable Mention, 1997 |
| Once a Knight door Christina Dodd | Most Tortured Hero - Honorable Mention, 1997 |
| River Of Fire door Mary Jo Putney | Most Tortured Hero - Honorable Mention, 1997 |
| Scoundrel door Elizabeth Elliott | Favorite Heroine - Honorable Mention, 1997 |
| Shades of Twilight door Linda Howard | Most Luscious Love Story - Honorable Mention, 1997 |
| Shattered Rainbows door Mary Jo Putney | Most Tortured Hero - Honorable Mention, 1997 |
| The Shattered Rose door Jo Beverley | Most-Hanky Read - Honorable Mention, 1997 |
| Simple Jess door Pamela Morsi | Favorite Hero - Honorable Mention, 1997 |
| Sunrise Song door Kathleen Eagle | Most-Hanky Read, 1997 |
| Vermoord in extase door J. D. Robb | Favorite Romance of the Year - Honorable Mention, 1997 |
| Vermoord naakt door J. D. Robb | Feistiest Heroine, 1997 |
| Vermoorde schoonheid door J. D. Robb | Favorite Couple, 1997 |
| The Wedding door Julie Garwood | Favorite Funny - Honorable Mention, 1997 |
| A Willing Spirit door Deb Stover | Favorite Heroine - Honorable Mention, 1997 |
| All Through the Night door Connie Brockway | Most-Hanky Read - Honorable Mention, 1998 |
| As You Desire door Connie Brockway | Most Luscious Love Story, 1998 |
| Baby, Baby door Susan Elizabeth Phillips | Favorite Romance of the Year, 1998 |
| Brighter than the Sun door Julia Quinn | Favorite Funny - Honorable Mention, 1998 |
| A Christmas Bride door Mary Balogh | Favorite Regency Romance, 1998 |
| Cupid's Mistake door Karen Harbaugh | Favorite Regency Romance - Honorable Mention, 1998 |
| Echoes of Tomorrow door Jenny Lykins | Feistiest Heroine, 1998 |
| Finding the Dream door Nora Roberts | Most Luscious Love Story - Honorable Mention, 1998 |
| A Knight to Remember door Christina Dodd | Favorite Medieval Romance - Honorable Mention, 1998 |
| My Sweet Folly door Laura Kinsale | Most Tortured Hero - Honorable Mention, 1998 |
| One Perfect Rose door Mary Jo Putney | Most-Hanky Read, 1998 |
| The Promise of Jenny Jones door Maggie Osborne | Most-Hanky Read - Honorable Mention, 1998 |
| The Randolph Legacy door Eileen Charbonneau | Favorite Hero - Honorable Mention, 1998 |
| Rejar door Dara Joy | Most Luscious Love Story - Honorable Mention, 1998 |
| Ritual Sins door Anne Stuart | Favorite Romantic Suspense - Honorable Mention, 1998 |
| De schuilplaats door Nora Roberts | Favorite Romantic Suspense - Honorable Mention, 1998 |
| Some Like It Hotter door Deb Stover | Most Luscious Love Story - Honorable Mention, 1998 |
| Son of the Morning door Linda Howard | Favorite Romantic Suspense, 1998 |
| Texas Destiny door Lorraine Heath | Most Tortured Hero - Honorable Mention, 1998 |
| This is all I ask door Lynn Kurland | Most-Hanky Read - Honorable Mention, 1998 |
| Vermoord uit wraak door J. D. Robb | Feistiest Heroine, 1998 |
| Het vuur van de herfst door Diana Gabaldon | Favorite Couple - Honorable Mention, 1998 |
| A Well Pleasured Lady door Christina Dodd | Most Luscious Love Story - Honorable Mention, 1998 |
| Wild at Heart door Patricia Gaffney | Most Luscious Love Story - Honorable Mention, 1998 |
| With This Ring door Carla Kelly | Favorite Regency Romance - Honorable Mention, 1998 |
| Wonderful door Jill Barnett | Favorite Medieval Romance, 1998 |
| Baby, I'm Yours door Susan Andersen | Favorite Road Romance, 1999 |
| Best Laid Schemes door Emma Jensen | Favorite Regency Romance - Honorable Mention, 1999 |
| Cherish door Catherine Anderson | Favorite American or Western Historical Romance - Honorable Mention, 1999 |
| Devil's Bride door Stephanie Laurens | Favorite Hero - Honorable Mention, 1999 |
| Dream a Little Dream door Susan Elizabeth Phillips | Most-Hanky Read, 1999 |
| Holiday in Death door J. D. Robb | Feistiest Heroine - Honorable Mention, 1999 |
| Irresistible door Mary Balogh | Favorite Regency Romance, 1999 |
| Kill and Tell: A Novel door Linda Howard | Favorite Romantic Suspense, 1999 |
| The Last Hellion door Loretta Chase | Feistiest Heroine, 1999 |
| Lord of Midnight door Jo Beverley | Favorite Medieval Romance, 1999 |
| Mine to Take door Dara Joy | Most Luscious Love Story, 1999 |
| My Darling Caroline door Adele Ashworth | Favorite Heroine - Honorable Mention, 1999 |
| My Dearest Enemy door Connie Brockway | Feistiest Heroine - Honorable Mention, 1999 |
| My Man Pendleton door Elizabeth Bevarly | Favorite Funny, 1999 |
| Nobody's Darling door Teresa Medeiros | Favorite American or Western Historical Romance - Honorable Mention, 1999 |
| Texas Glory door Lorraine Heath | Favorite American or Western Historical Romance, 1999 |
| To Catch an Heiress door Julia Quinn | Favorite Funny, 1999 |
| Wild door Jill Barnett | Favorite Medieval Romance - Honorable Mention, 1999 |
| Zeezucht door Nora Roberts | Favorite Romance of the Year, 1999 |
| Zwarte magie door Jo Beverley | Favorite European Historical Romance - Honorable Mention, 1999 |
| All the Queen's Men door Linda Howard | Favorite Villain, 2000 |
| Fair Game door Diane Farr | Favorite Regency Romance, 2000 |
| How to Marry a Marquis door Julia Quinn | Favorite European Historical Romance, 2000 |
| Lady Be Good door Susan Elizabeth Phillips | Favorite Romance of the Year - Honorable Mention, 2000 |
| The Lady's Tutor door Robin Schone | Favorite Romance of the Year, 2000 |
| Loyalty in Death door J. D. Robb | Favorite Hero, 2000 |
| My Beloved door Karen Ranney | Most Tortured Hero, 2000 |
| The Proposition door Judith Ivory | Favorite Romance of the Year - Honorable Mention, 2000 |
| Ransom door Julie Garwood | Favorite Cabin or Road Romance, 2000 |
| A Rogue in Texas door Lorraine Heath | Favorite American or Western Historical Romance, 2000 |
| Wicked door Jill Barnett | Most-Hanky Read, 2000 |
| By Arrangement door Madeline Hunter | Favorite Medieval Romance, 2001 |
| Dark Challenge door Christine Feehan | Favorite "Other" Romance - Honorable Mention, 2001 |
| Dark Magic door Christine Feehan | Favorite "Other" Romance - Honorable Mention, 2001 |
| I Do, I Do, I Do door Maggie Osborne | Favorite American or Western Historical Romance, 2001 |
| Falling for Chloë door Diane Farr | Favorite Regency Romance, 2001 |
| Get Lucky door Suzanne Brockmann | Favorite Series/Category Romance, 2001 |
| A Grand Design door Emma Jensen | Favorite Regency Romance, 2001 |
| Jackpot! door Jennifer Crusie | Favorite Romance of the Year - Honorable Mention, 2001 |
| Mr. Perfect door Linda Howard | Favorite Romantic Suspense, 2001 |
| Never Love a Cowboy door Lorraine Heath | Favorite American or Western Historical Romance - Honorable Mention, 2001 |
| A Secret Love door Stephanie Laurens | Most Luscious Love Story, 2001 |
| Star King door Susan Grant | Favorite "Other" Romance, 2001 |
| The Unsung Hero door Suzanne Brockmann | Most-Hanky Read, 2001 |
| The Viscount Who Loved Me: The 2nd Epilogue door Julia Quinn | Favorite Funny, 2001 |
| Where Dreams Begin door Lisa Kleypas | Favorite European Historical Romance - Honorable Mention, 2001 |
| Winter Garden door Adele Ashworth | Favorite Romance of the Year, 2001 |
| A Woman of Virtue door Liz Carlyle | Favorite European Historical Romance - Honorable Mention, 2001 |
| Beyond Innocence door Emma Holly | Most Luscious Love Story - Honorable Mention, 2002 |
| By Design door Madeline Hunter | Favorite Medieval - Honorable Mention, 2002 |
| Danegeld door Susan Squires | Favorite Medieval, 2002 |
| Darkling I Listen door Katherine Sutcliffe | Favorite Romantic Suspense - Honorable Mention, 2002 |
| Gabriel's Woman door Robin Schone | Most-Hanky Read - Honorable Mention, 2002 |
| The Indiscretion door Judith Ivory | Favorite Cabin or Road Romance, 2002 |
| Kiss of the Highlander door Karen Marie Moning | Favorite Alternate Reality, 2002 |
| Laat mij maar even door Jennifer Crusie | [HM] Favorite Funny [Tie], 2002 |
| Een liefde in Leningrad door Paullina Simons | Most-Hanky Read - Honorable Mention, 2002 |
| My Lord de Burgh door Deborah Simmons | Favorite Medieval - Honorable Mention, 2002 |
| An Offer From A Gentleman door Julia Quinn | Favorite European Historical Romance - Honorable Mention, 2002 |
| One Good Turn door Carla Kelly | Most-Hanky Read, 2002 |
| Open Season door Linda Howard | Favorite Contemporary - Honorable Mention, 2002 |
| The Outlaw and the Lady door Lorraine Heath | Favorite American Historical, 2002 |
| Over the Edge door Suzanne Brockmann | Favorite Romance of 2001 [Presented 2002], Favorite Contemporary, Favorite Romantic Suspense, Favorite Couple [Tie], Favorite Hero [Tie], Favorite Heroine, 2002 |
| The Protector door Madeline Hunter | Favorite Medieval, 2002 |
| Ritual of Proof door Dara Joy | Favorite Alternate Reality, 2002 |
| Star Prince door Susan Grant | Favorite Alternate Reality - Honorable Mention, 2002 |
| Suddenly You door Lisa Kleypas | Most Luscious Love Story, 2002 |
| Taylor's Temptation door Suzanne Brockmann | Favorite Series/Category, 2002 |
| This Heart of Mine door Susan Elizabeth Phillips | [HM] Favorite Funny [Tie], 2002 |
| True Confessions door Rachel Gibson | Favorite Funny, 2002 |
| Het vlammende kruis door Diana Gabaldon | Favorite American Historical - Honorable Mention, 2002 |
| All a Man Can Do door Virginia Kantra | [HM] Best Series Romance, 2003 |
| Beyond Seduction door Emma Holly | Most Luscious Love Story, 2003 |
| Bridal Favors door Connie Brockway | [HM] Favorite Funny [Tie], 2003 |
| Claiming the Highlander door Kinley MacGregor | [HM] Best Medieval, 2003 |
| Contact door Susan Grant | Best Alternate Reality, 2003 |
| Daughter of the Game door Tracy Grant | [HM] Best Romantic Suspense [Tie], 2003 |
| Dragonswan door Sherrilyn Kenyon | [HM] Best Short Story [Tie], 2003 |
| Faking It door Jennifer Crusie | Favorite Funny, 2003 |
| Fantasy Lover door Sherrilyn Kenyon | [HM] Guiltiest Pleasure, 2003 |
| Lady Sophia's Lover door Lisa Kleypas | Best Villain, 2003 |
| Lola geeft zich bloot door Rachel Gibson | [HM] Favorite Funny [Tie], 2003 |
| No Place Like Home door Barbara Samuel | Most-Hanky Read, 2003 |
| No True Gentleman door Liz Carlyle | Best Buried Treasure, 2003 |
| The Older Woman door Cheryl Reavis | Best Series Romance, 2003 |
| Once Upon a Pillow [Anthology 4-in-1] door Christina Dodd | [HM] Best Short Story [Tie], 2003 |
| Out of Control door Suzanne Brockmann | Best Romance for 2002 [Awarded 2003], Best Cabin/Road Romance, Best Contemporary, Best Romantic Suspense, Best Hero, 2003 |
| Prairie Moon door Maggie Osborne | Best Amer Hist/Frontier, 2003 |
| Purity in Death door J. D. Robb | [HM] Strongest Heroine [Tie], [HM] Best Couple [Tie], 2003 |
| A Regency Christmas [2002: Solid Silver Chess Set/ No Room at the Inn/ Amiable Miser/ Partridge in a Pear Tree/ Home for Hannah] door Sandra Heath | Best Short Story, 2003 |
| Reunion in Death door J. D. Robb | [HM] Strongest Heroine [Tie], [HM] Best Couple [Tie], 2003 |
| Romancing Mister Bridgerton door Julia Quinn | Best Heroine, Best Couple, [HM] Best European Historical, [HM] Favorite Funny [Tie], 2003 |
| The Seduction door Julia Ross | [HM] Best Buried Treasure, 2003 |
| The Spiral Path door Mary Jo Putney | Most Tortured Hero, [HM] Most-Hanky Read, 2003 |
| Stealing Heaven door Madeline Hunter | Best Medieval, 2003 |
| A Summer to Remember door Mary Balogh | [HM] Best Romance for 2002 [Awarded 2003], Author Most Glommed, [HM] Best European Historical [Tie], 2003 |
| Tapestry [Anthology] door Lynn Kurland | [HM] Best Short Story [Tie], 2003 |
| Too Much Temptation door Lori Foster | Guiltiest Pleasure, 2003 |
| Tot Het Uiterste door Linda Howard | [HM] Best Romantic Suspense [Tie], 2003 |
| Untie My Heart door Judith Ivory | Best European Historical, [HM] Most Luscious Love Story, [HM] Best Hero, 2003 |
| Waterblauw door Nora Roberts | [HM] Best Contemporary, 2003 |
| The Wedding Journey door Carla Kelly | Best Traditional Regency, [HM] Best Cabin/Road Romance, 2003 |
| Bad Moon Rising door Katherine Sutcliffe | [HM] Most Tortured Hero [Tie], 2004 |
| Beyond Sunrise door Candice Proctor | Best Cabin/Road Romance, 2004 |
| Body Check door Deirdre Martin | Best New Author, 2004 |
| Born in Sin door Kinley MacGregor | Best Medieval, [HM] Most Tortured Hero [Tie], 2004 |
| Cry No More door Linda Howard | Best Romantic Suspense, Most-Hanky Read, Best Heroine, Strongest Heroine, [HM] Best Romance, [HM] Best Hero, 2004 |
| Dance with the Devil door Sherrilyn Kenyon | Most Tortured Hero [Tie], 2004 |
| The Devil You Know door Liz Carlyle | [HM] Most Tortured Hero, 2004 |
| Fallen from Grace door Laura Leone | Best Buried Treasure, Most Tortured Hero [Tie], [HM] Best Contemporary Romance, 2004 |
| Gone Too Far door Suzanne Brockmann | Best Romance, Best Couple, [HM] Best Cabin/Road Romance, 2004 |
| Here's to the Ladies: Stories of the Frontier Army door Carla Kelly | Best Amer Hist/Frontier, [HM] Best Short Story for "Kathleen Flaherty's Long Winter" [Tie], 2004 |
| The Ideal Bride (Zebra Regency Romance) door Nonnie St. George | Best Traditional Regency, 2004 |
| The Last of the Honky-tonk Angels door Marsha Moyer | Best Chick Lit/Women's Fiction, 2004 |
| Lover Beware (Anthology 4-in-1) door Christine Feehan | [HM] Best Short Story [Tie], 2004 |
| Night Watch door Suzanne Brockmann | Best Series Romance, 2004 |
| Portrait in Death door J. D. Robb | Best Alternate Reality, Best Hero, 2004 |
| See Jane Score door Rachel Gibson | Best Contemporary, [HM] Best Heroine [Tie], 2004 |
| Slightly Married door Mary Balogh | Best European Historical, Author Most Glommed, 2004 |
| Slightly Scandalous door Mary Balogh | [HM] Best Villain, Author Most Glommed, 2004 |
| Some Men's Dreams door Kathleen Korbel | [HM] Best Series Romance, 2004 |
| Standing in the Shadows door Shannon McKenna | Guiltiest Pleasure, Best Villain, 2004 |
| Still Life with Murder door P. B. Ryan | [HM] Best Buried Treasure, 2004 |
| Take a Chance on Me door Susan Donovan | Favorite Funny, 2004 |
| To Sir Phillip, With Love door Julia Quinn | [HM] Best European Historical [Tie], 2004 |
| Under the Mistletoe (5 in 1 anthology) door Mary Balogh | [HM] Best Short Story for "A Family Christmas" [Tie], 2004 |
| De vrouw van de tijdreiziger door Audrey Niffenegger | [HM] Best Alternate Reality, 2004 |
| Where's My Hero? door Lisa Kleypas | Best Short Story, 2004 |
| Worth Any Price door Lisa Kleypas | Most Luscious Love Story, [HM] Best European Historical [Tie], 2004 |
| A.K.A. Goddess door Evelyn Vaughn | Best Series Novel, 2005 |
| Ain't She Sweet? door Susan Elizabeth Phillips | [HM] Strongest Heroine, [HM] Best Heroine, 2005 |
| Courting Trouble (Zebra Regency Romance) door Nonnie St. George | Best Traditional Regency, 2005 |
| The Damsel in This Dress door Marianne Stillings | Favorite New Author, 2005 |
| Dream of Me door Lisa Cach | [HM] Best Villain [Tie], 2005 |
| The Duke of Sin door Adele Ashworth | Most Luscious Love Story, 2005 |
| Flashpoint door Suzanne Brockmann | [HM] Best Romantic Suspense, [HM] Best Villain [Tie], 2005 |
| Foxfire Bride door Maggie Osborne | Best Amer Hist/Frontier, 2005 |
| Joint Forces door Catherine Mann | [HM] Best Series Novel, 2005 |
| Kiss Me While I Sleep: A Novel door Linda Howard | Best Romantic Suspense, Strongest Heroine, Best Villain, 2005 |
| Moon in the Water door Elizabeth Grayson | [HM] Best Amer Hist/Frontier, 2005 |
| My Seduction door Connie Brockway | Best Cabin/Road Romance, [HM] Best Villain [Tie], 2005 |
| Night Play door Sherrilyn Kenyon | Guiltiest Pleasure, Author Most Glommed, [HM] Best Alternate Reality, [HM] Best Hero [Tie], 2005 |
| Het noorderlicht door Nora Roberts | [HM] Best Hero [Tie], 2005 |
| Shadowheart door Laura Kinsale | Best Medieval/Renaissance, Most Tortured Hero, [HM] Most Luscious Love Story, 2005 |
| Slightly Dangerous door Mary Balogh | Best European Historical, Best Hero, [HM] Author Most Glommed, [HM] Best Couple, 2005 |
| Undead and Unwed door MaryJanice Davidson | Best Alternate Reality, [HM] Favorite Funny, 2005 |
| Under a Lucky Star door Diane Farr | Best Buried Treasure, 2005 |
| De weddenschap door Jennifer Crusie | Best Romance, Best Chick Lit/Women's Fiction, Best Contemporary, Best Couple, Best Heroine, Favorite Funny, [HM] Best Hero [Tie], 2005 |
| Wedding Belles (Anthology 5-in-1) door Allison Lane | Best Romance Short Story, 2005 |
| When He Was Wicked door Julia Quinn | Most-Hanky Read, 2005 |
| Black Ice door Anne Stuart | Best Romantic Suspense, Most Tortured Hero, 2006 |
| Dark Lover door J. R. Ward | Best Alt Reality/Paranormal, 2006 |
| Dedication door Janet Mullany | Best Traditional Regency, 2006 |
| Een duivelse date door Susan Elizabeth Phillips | Best Contemporary, Favorite Funny, 2006 |
| The Givenchy Code door Julie Kenner | Best Chick Lit/Women's Fiction, 2006 |
| Hot Spell (Anthology 4-in-1) door Emma Holly | ]HM] Best Romance Short Story, 2006 |
| It Happened One Autumn door Lisa Kleypas | Best Villain, 2006 |
| Mr. Impossible door Loretta Chase | Best Romance, Best Cabin/Road Romance, Best Couple, Best European Historical, Best Hero, [HM] Best Heroine, [HM] Author Most Glommed, 2006 |
| The Music of the Night (Signet Eclipse) door Lydia Joyce | Best Buried Treasure, 2006 |
| The Mysterious Miss M door Diane Gaston | Best Series Novel [Tie], 2006 |
| Passion door Lisa Valdez | Guiltiest Pleasure, Most Luscious Love Story, Best New Author, [HM] Best Buried Treasure [Tie], [HM] Most Hanky Read, 2006 |
| The Perfect Rake door Anne Gracie | [HM] Best Buried Treasure [Tie], 2006 |
| Return of the Warrior door Kinley MacGregor | Best Medieval/Renaissance, 2006 |
| Sneeuw en As door Diana Gabaldon | Best Amer Hist/Frontier Romance, Most Hanky Read [Tie], 2006 |
| Survivor In Death door J. D. Robb | Strongest Heroine, 2006 |
| Till Next We Meet door Karen Ranney | Most Hanky Read [Tie], 2006 |
| To Die For: A Novel door Linda Howard | Best Heroine, [HM] Best Chick Lit/Women's Fiction, [HM] Best Romantic Suspense [Tie], [HM] Favorite Funny, [HM] Strongest Heroine, 2006 |
| Warprize door Elizabeth Vaughan | [HM] Best Medieval/Renaissance, 2006 |
| With Child : 9 Months Later (Harlequin Superromance No. 1273) door Janice Kay Johnson | Best Series Novel [Tie], 2006 |
| All U Can Eat door Emma Holly | Best Erotic Romance, Guiltiest Pleasure, 2007 |
| Beauty and the Spy door Julie Anne Long | [HM] Best Buried Treasure [Tie], 2007 |
| Cold As Ice door Anne Stuart | Best Romantic Suspense, 2007 |
| The Devil in Winter door Lisa Kleypas | Best European Historical, Best Hero, Best Heroine, [HM] Best Couple [Tie], [HM] Guiltiest Pleasure, [HM] Most Luscious Love Story, 2007 |
| Drop Dead Gorgeous door Linda Howard | Best Contemporary, [HM] Best Heroine [Tie], [HM] Favorite Funny, 2007 |
| Family at Stake door Molly O'Keefe | Best Series, 2007 |
| Hot Dish door Connie Brockway | Best Chick Lit/Woman's Fiction, 2007 |
| Innocent in Death door J. D. Robb | Best Villain, 2007 |
| Jacob door Jacquelyn Frank | Best Buried Treasure, 2007 |
| Lord Perfect door Loretta Chase | Best Cabin/Road Romance, Best Couple, Favorite Funny, [HM] Best Romance, [HM] Best European Historical, [HM] Best Heroine [Tie], [HM] Strongest Heroine [Tie], 2007 |
| Lover Awakened door J. R. Ward | Best Romance, Best Paranormal, Best Villain, Most-Hanky Read, Most Tortured Hero, Strongest Heroine, Author Most Glommed, [HM] Best Couple [Tie], 2007 |
| Memory in Death door J. D. Robb | [HM] Strongest Heroine, 2007 |
| Een nieuw begin door Nora Roberts | [HM] Best Contemporary [Tie], [HM] Best Romantic Suspense, 2007 |
| The Raven Prince door Elizabeth Hoyt | Most Luscious Love Story, Best New Author, [HM] Best Buried Treasure [Tie], 2007 |
| A Reason to Live (Forrester Brothers) door Maureen McKade | Best Amer Hist/Frontier [Tie], 2007 |
| The Rogue's Return door Jo Beverley | Best Amer Hist/Frontier [Tie], 2007 |
| Santa, Baby door Jennifer Crusie | Best Romance Short Story, 2007 |
| The Silver Rose door Susan Carroll | Best Medieval, 2007 |
| Simply Love door Mary Balogh | [HM] Most Hanky Read, 2007 |
| Summer at Willow Lake door Susan Wiggs | [HM] Best Chick Lit/Woman's Fiction, 2007 |
| Undercover lover door Rachel Gibson | [HM] Best Contemporary [Tie], 2007 |
| The Warlord Wants Forever door Kresley Cole | [HM] Best Romance Short Story, 2007 |
| And Then He Kissed Her door Laura Lee Guhrke | Best Heroine, 2008 |
| Beat of Temptation (short story) door Nalini Singh | Best Romance Short Story, 2008 |
| Beau Crusoe door Carla Kelly | Most Hanky Read, [HM] Most Tortured Hero, 2008 |
| The Billionaire Next Door door Jessica Bird | Best Series/Category Novel, 2008 |
| Caine's Reckoning door Sarah McCarty | Best Amer Hist/Frontier, 2008 |
| Caressed by Ice door Nalini Singh | Best Paranormal & Time Travel Romance, 2008 |
| Claiming the Courtesan door Anna Campbell | Best New Author, [HM] Guiltiest Pleasure [Tie], 2008 |
| Creation in Death door J. D. Robb | Best Couple, Strongest Heroine, 2008 |
| Dangerous Lover door Lisa Marie Rice | [HM] Most Luscious Love Story [Tie], 2008 |
| Driven door Eve Kenin | Best Cabin/Road Romance [Tie], [HM] Best Sci-Fi/Fantasy & Futuristic Romance, 2008 |
| Fairyville door Emma Holly | Best Erotic Romance, 2008 |
| Games of Command door Linnea Sinclair | Best Sci-Fi/Fantasy & Futuristic Romance, 2008 |
| Het heetst van de dag door Nora Roberts | Best Romantic Suspense, 2008 |
| If His Kiss Is Wicked door Jo Goodman | Best Romance [Tie], Best Buried Treasure, Best European Historical, Best Hero, 2008 |
| Laird of the Mist door Paula Quinn | Best Medieval/Renaissance, 2008 |
| Lover Revealed door J. R. Ward | Guiltiest Pleasure, Author Most Glommed, 2008 |
| Lover Unbound door J. R. Ward | Most Tortured Hero, [HM] Guiltiest Pleasure [Tie], 2008 |
| Mine Till Midnight door Lisa Kleypas | [HM] Best Hero, [HM] Most Luscious Love Story [Tie], 2008 |
| Natural Born Charmer door Susan Elizabeth Phillips | Best Contemporary, Favorite Funny, [HM] Best Romance, 2008 |
| The Serpent Prince door Elizabeth Hoyt | Best Romance [Tie], Most Luscious Love Story, [HM] Best European Historical, 2008 |
| Sterf voor mij door Karen Rose | [HM] Best Villain, 2008 |
| Sugar Daddy door Lisa Kleypas | Best Chick Lit/Woman's Fiction, 2008 |
| Up Close and Dangerous: A Novel door Linda Howard | Best Cabin/Road Romance [Tie], 2008 |
| Blue-Eyed Devil door Lisa Kleypas | Best Contemporary Romance, Best Romance Hero, Biggest Tearjerker, 2009 |
| Broken Wing door Judith James | [HM] Biggest Tearjerker, 2009 |
| Dangerous Secrets door Lisa Marie Rice | [HM] Best Erotica, 2009 |
| Dark Desires After Dusk door Kresley Cole | [HM] Best Paranormal Romance [Tie], 2009 |
| Death Angel: A Novel door Linda Howard | Best Romantic Suspense, 2009 |
| It Happened One Night [Anthology 4-in-1] door Stephanie Laurens | Best Romance Short Story, 2009 |
| Just One of the Guys door Kristan Higgins | Best Chick Lit/Women's Fiction, [HM] Funniest Romance [Tie], 2009 |
| Ken je me nog? door Sophie Kinsella | Best Chick Lit/Women's Fiction, 2009 |
| Like No Other Lover door Julie Anne Long | [HM] Funniest Romance [Tie], 2009 |
| The Lost Duke of Wyndham door Julia Quinn | [HM] Funniest Romance [Tie], 2009 |
| Lover Enshrined door J. R. Ward | Best Paranormal Romance, Guiltiest Pleasure Romance, 2009 |
| Mine to Possess door Nalini Singh | [HM] Best Paranormal Romance [Tie], 2009 |
| A Most Unconventional Match door Julia Justiss | Best Series Romance, 2009 |
| Not Another Bad Date door Rachel Gibson | Funniest Romance, 2009 |
| Private Arrangements door Sherry Thomas | Best Debut Author, [HM] Best Historical Romance Set in the U.K., 2009 |
| Queen of Babble Gets Hitched door Meg Cabot | [HM] Best Chick Lit/Women's Fiction [Tie], 2009 |
| The Spymaster's Lady door Joanna Bourne | Best Romance, Best Historical Romance Set in the U.K., Best Romance Couple, Best Romance Heroine, [HM] Best Romance Hero, 2009 |
| To Seduce a Sinner door Elizabeth Hoyt | Best Love Scenes in a Mainstream Romance [Tie], 2009 |
| To Taste Temptation door Elizabeth Hoyt | [HM] Best Love Scenes in a Mainstream Romance, 2009 |
| Wicked Burn door Beth Kery | Best Erotica, 2009 |
| Your Scandalous Ways door Loretta Chase | Best Love Scenes in a Mainstream Romance [Tie], 2009 |
| Bound by Your Touch door Meredith Duran | Best Romance Couple, Best Romance Heroine, [HM] Best Historical Romance Set in the U.K., [HM] Best Love Scenes in Mainstream Romance [Tie], [HM] Best Romance [Tie], 2010 |
| Branded by Fire door Nalini Singh | Best Paranormal Romance, [HM] Best Love Scenes in Mainstream Romance [Tie], 2010 |
| Dark of Night door Suzanne Brockmann | Best Romantic Suspense, 2010 |
| The Heart of Christmas door Mary Balogh | Best Romance Short Story, 2010 |
| Lover Avenged door J. R. Ward | Guiltiest Pleasure Romance, [HM] Best Paranormal Romance, 2010 |
| The Madness of Lord Ian Mackenzie door Jennifer Ashley | Best Historical Romance Set in the U.K., Best Love Scenes in Mainstream Romance [Tie], Best Romance, Most Tortured Hero, [HM] Best Romance Heroine, 2010 |
| Marrying The Captain (Harlequin Historical Series) door Carla Kelly | Best Series Romance, 2010 |
| Not Quite a Husband door Sherry Thomas | Best Historical Romance Not Set in the U.K., Biggest Tearjerker, [HM] Best Romance [Tie], [HM] Best Romance Heroine [Tie], 2010 |
| Red's Hot Honky-Tonk Bar door Pamela Morsi | Best Chick Lit/Women's Fiction, 2010 |
| Smooth Talking Stranger door Lisa Kleypas | Best Contemporary Romance, Best Love Scenes in Mainstream Romance [Tie], Best Romance Hero, 2010 |
| The Surgeon's Lady (Harlequin Historical Series) door Carla Kelly | [HM] Best Series Romance, 2010 |
| What Happens in London door Julia Quinn | Funniest Romance, 2010 |
| All I Ever Wanted door Kristan Higgins | Best Chick Lit/Women's Fiction, 2011 |
| The Bikini Car Wash door Pamela Morsi | Best Chick Lit/Women's Fiction, 2011 |
| The Forbidden Rose (Berkley Sensation Historical Romance) door Joanna Bourne | [HM] Best Romance, Best Historical Romance Not Set in the U.K., 2011 |
| The Iron Duke door Meljean Brook | [HM] Best Romance, Best Paranormal Romance, 2011 |
| Last Night's Scandal door Loretta Chase | Best Romance, Best Historical Romance Set in the U.K., 2011 |
| Love in the Afternoon door Lisa Kleypas | [HM] Best Historical Romance Set in the U.K., Biggest Tearjerker, 2011 |
| Lover Mine door J. R. Ward | [HM] Best Paranormal Romance, Guiltiest Pleasure Romance, 2011 |
| Marrying the Royal Marine (Harlequin Historical) door Carla Kelly | Best Series Romance, 2011 |
| Naked Edge door Pamela Clare | Best Romantic Suspense, 2011 |
| Patience door Lisa Valdez | Best Romantica, 2011 |
| Spanning! door Julie James | Best Contemporary Romance, 2011 |
| Ten Things I Love About You door Julia Quinn | Funniest Romance, 2011 |
| What the Librarian Did door Karina Bliss | [HM] Best Series Romance, 2011 |
| Wicked Intentions door Elizabeth Hoyt | Best Love Scenes (in a Mainstream Romance), 2011 |
| The Admiral's Penniless Bride door Carla Kelly | [HM] Best Category Romance, 2012 |
| All They Need door Sarah Mayberry | [HM] Best Category Romance, 2012 |
| The Black Hawk (Berkley Sensation) door Joanna Bourne | Best Romance, Best Historical Romance Not Set in the U.K., Biggest Tearjerker, 2012 |
| Breaking Point door Pamela Clare | Best Romantic Suspense, 2012 |
| Call Me Irresistible door Susan Elizabeth Phillips | Funniest Romance, 2012 |
| Curio door Cara McKenna | [HM] Best Erotica/Romantica, 2012 |
| Dragon Bound door Thea Harrison | Best Paranormal Romance, 2012 |
| Just Like Heaven door Julia Quinn | [HM] Funniest Romance, 2012 |
| A Lot Like Love door Julie James | Best Contemporary Romance, Funniest Romance, 2012 |
| Lover Unleashed door J. R. Ward | Guiltiest Pleasure Romance, 2012 |
| My One and Only door Kristan Higgins | [HM] Best Chick Lit/Women's Fiction, 2012 |
| Notorious Pleasures door Elizabeth Hoyt | [HM] Best Love Scenes (in a Mainstream Romance), 2012 |
| The Other Guy's Bride door Connie Brockway | [HM] Best Historical Romance Not Set in the U.K., 2012 |
| The Perfect Play door Jaci Burton | Best Erotica/Romantica, 2012 |
| Seduction of a Highland Lass door Maya Banks | [HM] Biggest Tearjerker, 2012 |
| De smaak te pakken door Jill Mansell | Best Chick Lit/Women's Fiction, 2012 |
| Stranded With Her Ex door Jill Sorenson | Best Category Romance, 2012 |
| Vijftig Tinten Grijs door E. L. James | Best Erotica/Romantica, 2012 |
| What I Did for a Duke door Julie Anne Long | [HM] Best Romance, Best Historical Romance Set in the U.K., Best Love Scenes (in a Mainstream Romance), 2012 |
| When Beauty Tamed the Beast door Eloisa James | Biggest Tearjerker, 2012 |
| Yours to Keep door Shannon Stacey | [HM] Funniest Romance, 2012 |
| About That Night door Julie James | Best Contemporary Romance, 2013 |
| Bared to You door Sylvia Day | Best Erotica/Romantica, 2013 |
| Defiant door Pamela Clare | Best Historical Romance Not Set in the U.K., 2013 |
| The Governess Affair door Courtney Milan | Best Romance Short Story, 2013 |
| Lothaire door Kresley Cole | Best Paranormal Romance, 2013 |
| Mag ik je nummer even? door Sophie Kinsella | Best Chick Lit/Women's Fiction, 2013 |
| A Notorious Countess Confesses door Julie Anne Long | Best Romance, [HM] Best Historical Romance Set in the U.K., 2013 |
| De ooggetuige door Nora Roberts | Best Romantic Suspense, 2013 |
| Ravishing the Heiress door Sherry Thomas | [HM] Best Historical Romance Set in the U.K., Biggest Tearjerker, 2013 |
| Riveted door Meljean Brook | [HM] Best Paranormal Romance, 2013 |
| Suddenly You door Sarah Mayberry | Best Category Romance, 2013 |
| Thief of Shadows door Elizabeth Hoyt | Best Love Scenes (in a Mainstream Romance), 2013 |
| A Week to Be Wicked door Tessa Dare | Best Historical Romance Set in the U.K., Funniest Romance, 2013 |
| The Countess Conspiracy door Courtney Milan | Honorable Mention, 2014 |
| Eleanor & Park door Rainbow Rowell | Best Young Adult, 2014 |
| First Strike door Pamela Clare | Best Romance Short Story, 2014 |
| Foreplay door Sophie Jordan | Best New Adult, 2014 |
| Gebonden door Emma Chase | Funniest Romance, 2014 |
| Heart of Obsidian door Nalini Singh | Best Paranormal Romance, 2014 |
| The Lotus Palace door Jeannie Lin | AAR Annual Reader Poll, 2014 |
| Love Irresistibly door Julie James | Best Contemporary Romance, 2014 |
| The Luckiest Lady in London door Sherry Thomas | Best Romance, 2014 |
| One Good Earl Deserves a Lover door Sarah MacLean | Honorable Mention, 2014 |
| The Other Side of Us door Sarah Mayberry | Best Category Romance, 2014 |
| Het Rosie Project door Graeme Simsion | Best Novel with Strong Romantic Elements, 2014 |
| Snow-Kissed door Laura Florand | Biggest Tearjerker, 2014 |
| Striking Distance door Pamela Clare | Best Romantic Suspense, 2014 |
| Uncommon Passion door Anne Calhoun | Best Erotica/Romantica, 2014 |
| A Christmas Gone Perfectly Wrong door Cecilia Grant | Best Romance Short Story, 2015 |
| Fool Me Twice door Meredith Duran | Best Love Scenes (in a Mainstream Romance), 2015 |
| A Grave Matter door Anna Lee Huber | Best Novel with Strong Romantic Elements, 2015 |
| Having Her door Jackie Ashenden | Best Erotica/Romantica, 2015 |
| The Hook Up door Kristen Callihan | Best New Adult, 2015 |
| Isla and the Happily Ever After door Stephanie Perkins | Best Young Adult, 2015 |
| It Happened One Wedding door Julie James | Best Romance, 2015 |
| The Kraken King door Meljean Brook | Best Romantic Science Fiction, 2015 |
| Mr. (Not Quite) Perfect door Jessica Hart | Best Category Romance, 2015 |
| My Beautiful Enemy door Sherry Thomas | Best Historical Romance Not Set in the U.K., 2015 |
| Only Enchanting door Mary Balogh | Best Historical Romance Set in the U.K., 2015 |
| The Perilous Sea door Sherry Thomas | Honorable Mention, 2015 |
| De Redding door Jayne Ann Krentz | Best Romantic Suspense, 2015 |
| Rock Addiction door Nalini Singh | Honorable Mention, 2015 |
| Rogue Spy door Joanna Bourne | Honorable Mentions, 2015 |
| Shield of Winter door Nalini Singh | Best Paranormal Romance, 2015 |
| The Suffragette Scandal door Courtney Milan | Honorable Mention, 2015 |
| Think of England door KJ Charles | Best LGBT Romance, 2015 |
| Three Weeks with Lady X door Eloisa James | Honorable Mention, 2015 |
| The Winter King door C. L. Wilson | Best Romantic Fantasy Fiction, 2015 |
| Archangel's Enigma door Nalini Singh | Best Paranormal Romance, 2016 |
| Burned door Karen Marie Moning | Best Fantasy Romance, 2016 |
| Elements of Chemistry door Penny Reid | Best New Adult Romance, 2016 |
| Harlot door Victoria Dahl | Best Erotica / Romantica Romance, 2016 |
| Him door Sarina Bowen | Best LGBTQ+ Romance, 2016 |
| If You Only Knew door Kristan Higgins | Best Novel (non-romance) with strong romantic elements, 2016 |
| The Immortal Heights door Sherry Thomas | Best Young Adult Romance, 2016 |
| Lord Dashwood Missed Out [novella] door Tessa Dare | Best Romance Novella or Short Story, 2016 |
| Magic Shifts door Ilona Andrews | Best Kick-Ass Heroine, 2016 |
| My Kind of Wonderful door Jill Shalvis | Favorite Funny Romance, 2016 |
| Only a Kiss door Mary Balogh | Favorite Tear-Jerker Romance, 2016 |
| Playing by the Greek's Rules door Sarah Morgan | Best Category Romance Book, 2016 |
| Rock Hard door Nalini Singh | Best Romance Heroine, 2016 |
| Rock Redemption door Nalini Singh | Most Tortured Romance Hero, 2016 |
| A Seditious Affair door KJ Charles | Best LGBTQ+ Romance, 2016 |
| Seduction Game door Pamela Clare | Best Romantic Suspense, 2016 |
| Shards of Hope door Nalini Singh | Best Romance, 2016 |
| Siren's Call door Jayne Castle | Best Science Fiction Romance, 2016 |
| Sweetest Scoundrel door Elizabeth Hoyt | Most Luscious Love Story, 2016 |
| This Gun for Hire door Jo Goodman | Best Historical Romance set outside the U.K., 2016 |
