Another novel by Wilkins Freeman that is set in rural New England (I think in the 1800's but I don't know that the book says one way or the other). This one is a bit different because all of the main characters are quite flawed in one way or the other. Madelon, in particular, is too proud, too head-strong and too passionate. Burr is a weak man, but steps up to protect another. And Lot is so love-sick for Madelon (who is in love with Burr) that he can't even think straight. The only true joy in the book comes through the music of Madelon and her family. A satisfying read, but not a great one. ( )