Slow start, but eventually the dialogue between Mike, Other Mike, Lenny and Maria got very funny. However, I got VERY tired of all the references to girls being inferior. Even though ultimately the girl characters were awesome, the author seemed obsessed with the awesomeness being a big surprise. I think the assumed sexism was pretty outdated and boring - this is supposed to be a murder mystery, let's focus on that, not how shocking it is that a girl can be a baseball pitcher who strikes out boys! I really did chuckle when the kids, who were all likable, were being hilarious. The plot could've been snappier, though! ( )

Twelve year old Lenny, Mike, and Other Mike have been best friends for years. Mike and Lenny live, breathe and eat baseball, and know everything there is to know about their hometown heroes – the Philadelphia Phillies.

Read the rest of my review on my blog: http://shouldireaditornot.wordpress.com/2013/03/12/strike-three-youre-dead-josh-... ( )

[Originally published in 2014]

I hadn't expected to like this book - I have absolutely no interest in sports - but I picked it up off my backlog to read because I was looking for more middle grade mysteries (in expectation of the return of 80 5th graders next year, all clamoring for mysteries). To my surprise, I found it funny, engrossing, realistic, and just all-around fun.

Lenny and his two best friend, Mike and Other Mike, are looking forward to a leisurely summer and Lenny enters an "armchair announcer" contest for the Phillies, never expecting to win. But he does! Lenny is living the dream, meeting his heroes, getting ready to actually announce an inning...when a promising young baseball player drops dead. What really happened? Lenny and the Mikes, as well as their new friend Maria, are determined to find out.

There's plenty of sports information for the die-hard fan, but just as much mystery and humor for any other reader included as well. The characterization of the Lenny and his friends is spot-on hilarious, from Lenny's traumatic last baseball game to his more athletic friend Mike, and Other Mike's obsession with fantasy and computers. Maria is a great addition to the team with funny and awkward interactions between the kids as they try to figure out how to relate to this girl who's just as big a fan as them and is turning out to be nothing like they expected.

There's a great mystery, not too graphic but definitely not too little-kids-ish for the audience. There's awkward preteen boys interrogating librarians. There are mustaches. There's a tough girl who isn't ashamed of liking baseball. There's interesting things you can learn in books, like safecracking. And, of course, lots of baseball trivia.

Verdict: The sports mysteries I bought for teens have been gathering dust on the shelf, but this one will definitely be a popular choice for middle school readers who are interested in sports or mysteries. I am delighted to see it's going to be a series and the sequel, Say it ain't so! will be published next week.

Revisited: This has never been quite as popular as I think it should be, but it does circulate reliably when I booktalk it. It ended up being a trilogy and the first one, at least, is still available in prebound and paperback.

ISBN: 9780375870088; Published 2013 by Alfred A. Knopf/Random House; Review copy provided by the publisher; Purchased for the library

Lenny loves baseball and dreams of being an announcer someday (because he's certainly never going to be a player). It's just a dream until his two best friends, Mike and Other Mike, convince him to enter the Phillies' Armchair Announcer contest. On the night of the big game--the biggest opportunity of Lenny's life--an up-and-coming player drops dead on the mound. It's written off as a fluke thing, but Lenny and his friends find it more suspicious than that. Everyone who was in the stadium that night is a suspect and anything could be a lead in this fast-paced murder mystery.

A funny mystery for middle-school boys, particularly those interested in baseball. It's not a terribly difficult mystery to crack or a particularly sophisticated one, but the characters are engaging enough to carry the plot. A good choice for the kids who only want to read sports books when the Mysteries Book Report comes around.

Middle school sleuths will love this fun mystery. Fast paced and funny...you'll love it. ( )