When the class-overachiever, the head cheerleader, and the vegan discover they're all dating the same guy - star basketball player John Tucker - the girls decide to recruit a bashful new girl named Kate to break Tucker's bad boy heart. As Kate uses the girls' combined wiles to lure Tucker, his interest gives her a social standing she's never had before, but the intoxicating experience may cost her a chance at honest love with another boy. When the class-overachiever, the head cheerleader, and the vegan lover discover they're all dating the same guy - namely the star basketball player John Tucker - the girls decide to recruit a bashful new girl named Kate to become the ideal girl to break Tucker's bad boy heart. But as Kate uses the girls' combined wiles to lure Tucker, his interest gives her a social standing she's never had before. But the intoxicating experience may cost her a chance at honest love with another boy.