Klik op een omslag om naar Google Boeken te gaan.
Bezig met laden... A History of Native American Land Rights in Upstate New York (origineel 2016; editie 2016)door Cindy Amrhein (Auteur)
Informatie over het werkHistory of Native American Land Rights in Upstate New York door Cindy Amrhein (2016)
Geen Bezig met laden...
Meld je aan bij LibraryThing om erachter te komen of je dit boek goed zult vinden. Op dit moment geen Discussie gesprekken over dit boek. geen besprekingen | voeg een bespreking toe
A complex and troubled history defines the borders of upstate New York beyond the physical boundaries of its rivers and lakes. The United States and the state were often deceptive in their territory negotiations with the Iroquois Six Nations. Amidst the growing quest for more land among settlers and then fledgling Americans, the Indian nations attempted to maintain their autonomy. Yet state land continued to encroach the Six Nations. Local historian Cindy Amrhein takes a close and critical view of these transactions. Evidence of dubious deals, bribes, faulty surveys and coerced signatures may help explain why many of the Nations now feel they were cheated out of their territory. Geen bibliotheekbeschrijvingen gevonden. |
Actuele discussiesGeen
Google Books — Bezig met laden... GenresDewey Decimale Classificatie (DDC)324.6309747Social sciences Political Science The political process Suffrage, Voting Rights, Voting and Electoral SystemsLC-classificatieWaarderingGemiddelde:
|
Amrhein makes some interesting points; a major one is her contention that the original intent of the United States government was to treat Native American tribes as foreign nations and conclude treaties accordingly. In that regard, she cites two 1790 letters from George Washington to Alexander Hamilton (then Secretary of the Treasury) and to Seneca Chief Cornplanter, complaining that the State of New York and private individuals had conducted negotiations and bought land from the Six Nations, something only the Federal government had the power to do. This didn’t stop the State of New York from continuing to sell “unoccupied” Indian land.
Another interesting point is Amrhein’s argument that a treaty cannot convey land ownership; only a deed can do that. She claims that a treaty can proclaim the intent to convey land, but unless there’s also a deed, no land is transferred.
And there’s a discussion of an interesting personality – Eleazer Williams. Williams had been raised among the Mohawks and apparently considered himself an Indian, but he also seems to have presented himself as having much more influence among the Indians than he actually did – in particular negotiating treaties and signing documents on their behalf. As you might expect, this ended badly for the natives.
Still, the book as a whole is rather disappointing. The book needs an overall history of how US laws relating to Indians changed; instead Amrhein immediately dives into minutiae about land titles and deeds. Her citing of George Washington’s letters is an example; while Washington’s opinions are interesting, it’s the United States Senate, not the President, that makes treaties with foreign powers. She mentions the Indian Nonintercourse Act, but without going into any details. Finally her history basically stops in the 1800s, with little mention of later issues (for example, the Kinzua Dam or New York State’s attempts to collect sales taxes on Indian land). Also missing is a more extensive discussion of native attitudes toward real property.
Certainly worth reading, but I would have liked a longer book with more information. It did inspire me to do more research on my own. ( )