These are short stories by famous children’s authors, all with the same plot point – a child receives an empty box on their birthday. Everyone interprets this plot device differently, and it ends up being a fascinating book of stories (and a poem). The authors are all very recognizable to children, which would also make the book popular. And even though they all have the same plot device, it never gets old. The stories are very short, and all in all this would make a terrific choice for a reluctant reader. Hurwitz did a good job choosing the authors for this collection and the stories are first-rate. I can’t even choose a favorite story because they are all so different and strong. ( )