Ich habe dieses Buch in Deutsch vorgestellt - zusammen mit einem anderen. Es ist sehr traurig weil das Mädchen Alice mit dem Zug nach Auschwitz fährt. Unser Lehrer in Geschichte hat uns erzählt was dort passiert ist. Ich habe geweint als er es sagte. Die Reise von Alice in diesem Buch ist keine schöne Reise in die Ferien sondern eine ganz schlimme Reise. Das schlimmste ist, es ist so passiert für ganz viele Menschen. Das macht mich sehr traurig. Nach dem Buch habe ich gleich etwas lustiges gelesen weil ich wieder froh sein wollte. ( )

Extraordinary and brilliantly written. ( )

This is a harrowing fictional account of the journey of a young girl from innocence to knowledge, from home to Auschwitz, from life to death. The entire book takes place in the cattle car packed with Jews from all classes, all ages - all the subject of hatred by the Nazis. This was very difficult to read and even more difficult to contemplate when I was finished with the book. Still, I am glad that I read the book. It will give me pause for some time. ( )

There are a lot of books on the Holocaust but not many of them talk in detail about the actual journeys to the camps, the trains. This book, which is about as low-key as it can be given the topic, is about a twelve-year-old girl, Alice, being deported to Auschwitz, and almost the entire story takes place in the cattle car, packed in with dozens of other miserable Jews. The grimness and inhumanity of the surroundings is quite evident. The wretched people quickly fill their waste bucket and finally just eliminate in a corner, and eventually the whole car floods. A nice young man is shot to death when he tries to escape. Although it's not explicitly stated, Alice is sent to certain death in the last chapter of the book. However, more important is the protagonist's journey of self-discovery.

As the train rolls onward to its destination, so does Alice learn more and more things about her life that she never knew. Extremely naive in the beginning -- she was kept shut away by her loving grandfather and was completely unaware of the persecutions and the danger surrounding her -- Alice quickly wises up and realizes the (almost) entire truth of the situation. She begins to menstruate during the last pages, a symbol of her new emotional maturity.

Children would appreciate this book and I don't think it's too graphic for them, but adults will also appreciate it for the many layers of meaning in the story. ( )

This whole book takes place in a cattle car en route to a concentration camp. It might have benefited from having an adult protagonist. With a small 11 year old, one is never in any suspense about the journey's end. And I'm not sure that her horror about excrement and her innocence about why she had just spent all that time in a basement were really an effective way to get the story across. ( )