Since July 1863, survivors, historians and Civil War enthusiasts have debated, written about and dissected Robert E. Lee's defeat at Gettysburg. Myriad controversies concerning the conduct of the campaign and battle have provided fodder for discussion. Many disputants ignore consistent facts that refute their point of view. Longstreet's Assault -- Pickett's Charge offers a narratives-based review of the decisions made by the commanders on both sides.