I thought this was a pretty good book. It was one of those that you have to pay attention to what you are reading because it does bounce back and forth, but I did enjoy it. In allot of the reviews I read there were quite a few that did not like the ending, but I think it ended just as it should have, I wouldn't have wanted it any other way. But the author went on to write a sequel from what I understand because of the negative feedback about her ending. I have not read that book because I enjoyed how the first book ended, I mean for goodness sakes the ending made sense. Some people just don't know a good ending to a book when they read one I guess. Great writing Gayle Forman, I thought your ending rocked! ( )

I thought this was a pretty good book. It was one of those that you have to pay attention to what you are reading because it does bounce back and forth, but I did enjoy it. In allot of the reviews I read there were quite a few that did not like the ending, but I think it ended just as it should have, I wouldn't have wanted it any other way. But the author went on to write a sequel from what I understand because of the negative feedback about her ending. I have not read that book because I enjoyed how the first book ended, I mean for goodness sakes the ending made sense. Some people just don't know a good ending to a book when they read one I guess. Great writing Gayle Forman, I thought your ending rocked! ( )

A few days ago, I bought this collection in the Christmas department in the store, and I can't emphasize enough how this series was flying off the shelves! I think the girls were feeling what I felt watching "If I Stay" in the cinema two months ago. I fell in love with the movie deeply, so I had to get the books, and see what would happen to Mia and Adam. I also put both separate books on my Goodreads shelves because I don't like to mix things up. Once I'm done with both, you will find my reviews separated on each book. ( )

A few days ago, I bought this collection in the Christmas department in the store, and I can't emphasize enough how this series was flying off the shelves! I think the girls were feeling what I felt watching "If I Stay" in the cinema two months ago. I fell in love with the movie deeply, so I had to get the books, and see what would happen to Mia and Adam. I also put both separate books on my Goodreads shelves because I don't like to mix things up. Once I'm done with both, you will find my reviews separated on each book. ( )