I did not really like this book because of the illustrations but I did enjoy the main message. The illustrations were extremely simple and lacked details. They looked like they were drawn with pencils and color pencils. This was unappealing because the book was about a fun party with cake and ice cream, however, the pictures did not enhance the story. I feel that the book was a great opportunity to display exceptional illustrations.On the other hand, the main messages of determination and persistence were very appealing. Martin and Marvin used many resources, such as the baker and the ice-cream man, in order to throw an amazing Birthday party. The boys were very determined and never gave up. In the end, they had a very fun and exciting party. All of their hard work paid off! ( )

I had mixed feelings about this book after reading it. I liked the book because the characters were believable, Milton and Marvin's desire for a birthday party may relate to students whose parents do not throw them birthday parties. Also, students may relate to trying to make dessert but ultimately failing because they did not have a parents help.'"I think we need some expert advice," said Marvin' students may relate to a time where they needed expert advice on a situation. I did not like this book because it is not up to date, the pictures did not add anything extra to the story. The big idea of "Ice Cream Soup" is determination, Milton and Marvin were determined to have a birthday party and did not give up, they worked hard to achieve what they wanted. ( )