Alberto AlesinaBesprekingen
Auteur van The Size of Nations
Besprekingen
Onze site gebruikt cookies om diensten te leveren, prestaties te verbeteren, voor analyse en (indien je niet ingelogd bent) voor advertenties. Door LibraryThing te gebruiken erken je dat je onze Servicevoorwaarden en Privacybeleid gelezen en begrepen hebt. Je gebruik van de site en diensten is onderhevig aan dit beleid en deze voorwaarden.
However, historical analyses are unfortunately overshadowed by mathematical modeling in all the other chapters. The authors believe that the tradeoff can be used to 'explain' various aspects of state size. They derive a large set of mathematical equations which supposedly describe their relationships formally. However, the simplifications and assumptions behind the equations are extremely unrealistic, and consequently the derivations become vacuous formal exercises which yield absolutely no information of interest. I can't believe that professional academics waste their time, and fill their books, with such utterly pointless work.
Of course models are idealizations and they can be informative even if they don't correspond exactly to reality, as the authors note in defence of their method. But come on, sociology and history have limits where further abstraction becomes counterproductive. The authors probably crossed these limits so long ago, and are now so far beyond them, that they no longer remember where they lie. The benefits and drawbacks of small and large states are interesting topics for a historical discussion, and maybe a philosophical one as well. But it is simply not a good subject for mathematical analysis. That much quickly becomes clear to readers of this book, if not to its authors.