Rebecca BehrensBesprekingen

grades 3-7
Wisconsin Library Association's Children's Book Awards!

Independent Reading Level: Grades 3-7
Awards: Elizabeth Burr/Worzalla Award (Outstanding Books of the Year – 2020), Sunshine State Young Reader's Award (Nominee – Grades 3-5 – 2022), The Best Children's Books of the Year (2020)

Ages 8-12

children's fiction (modern day First Daughter and historical fiction/Alice Roosevelt).

*I was provided a free copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.*

Historical fiction was one of my very favorite subjects when I was about 10 — around the age group this book is written for, actually. So, I occasionally like to break up my adult reading with some children’s/middle grade reading just to make things interesting. What really drew me to this book was the fact that it had something to do with Roanoke, which is a fascinating topic.

There isn’t much of a waiting period in terms of getting things set up and then getting into the story — instead, the story starts right away and the reader is left to figure things out as it goes along. I love this. It’s my favorite way of reading, because I tend to skim over all those setup paragraphs. Give me something to hold on to, then I’ll trudge through location, description, etc. Behrens does that, which I so much appreciate. More than that, she starts off with a real, gripping topic: Nell’s dad’s toothbrush isn’t in the bathroom and he’s gone. It becomes apparent fairly quickly that something is happening between Nell’s parents, but she’s too scared to ask questions, so she goes along with it and accompanies her mother to a trip to North Carolina, around where the Roanoke colony was established.

Overall, I thought this book was really cute. As a ten-year-old, it probably would have been one of my favorites. Ghost stories, mysteries, historical fiction? Heck yes! Sign me up. As an adult, it doesn’t quite hold up in terms of complexity and story telling. I thought that the friendship between Nell and the girl she meets during her summer vacation to be strange, and I don’t think that current slang/technology was used to its best advantage. I’ve never personally heard a kid tell me, “She’s not really my friend, she’s my frenemy,” straight up like that. I think it’s more of an understood thing than a thing that kids actually say, but that might just be me. Nell also describes a lot of what she does on her cell phone, which might have been better used just as straight dialogue or text instead of summarized within the narration. Again, kind of nitpicky things that I don’t think will necessarily bother the age group/reading level this is written for.

What is great about this book is that I had a ton of questions about the actual historical colony of Roanoke, and I wanted to get my hands on history books about it right after I finished reading Summer of Lost and Found. I can see a younger reader having the same reaction, which means this might be a great companion piece/gateway to learning about some colonial history for kids. I also really love that it deals with a hard, complicated topic: parents not getting along and not dealing with it very well. It’s a great way for kids to take a look at coping mechanisms and ways of resolving conflict.

Most importantly, it’s just plain fun. I loved following Nell in her adventure to find the lost colony of Roanoke, making my own theories and guesses as she discovered more and more about the colony and the area. It was a cute story and a quick read that I think a lot of younger (and older) readers will appreciate.

Originally posted on Purple People Readers.½

Thirteen year old Audrey is a typical 21st century girl. She likes to watch movies, eat pizza, and has crushes on boys. She is also keen for a good adventure and making friends. However, Audrey is different than most girls her age in that she is the daughter of the President of the United States and lives in the White House. Restrictions of all sorts abound for Audrey, but when she discovers the diary of President Teddy Roosevelt’s daughter, Alice Roosevelt, she wants to follow Alice’s advice: “To Thine Own Self Be True.” What follows is a delightful story that shifts between Audrey’s ups and downs as a first daughter and Alice’s adventures and challenges as first daughter over 100 years earlier. Behrens masterfully illuminates how many of the girls’ experiences are similar though, despite the time gap. Readers will laugh and cringe at both Audrey and Alice’s adventures, which include crashing golf carts, hiding boys under beds, navigating multiple marriage proposals, and sneaking friends into the White House (in disguise!).

There aren’t many books out there that illuminate the contemporary experience of being a first daughter in the White House. Nor are there many stories that interweave a contemporary first daughter’s experience with an early 20th century experience of living at 1600. What a gem of a book! I recommend that readers, including middle grade, young adult, and adult readers sit down to read about the antics and challenges of first daughters Audrey Rhodes and Alice Roosevelt.

See full review on my blog

Girl who's mother is the President of the US and all of the problems that come with that. Friends not allowed in due to security breaches, friends who want to be friends because you are famous, end of old life. Etc. Could have been good.

To me a lot of the Alice Roosevelt stuff was not for children (which this book is supposedly written for) since it was just down right boring and full of trouble making that kids would not get into. Ahhh the horrors of driving a car as a woman or smoking on the roof of the White House. Not so much.

Even with that, I thought that it might work because we could discuss how families are too busy for us and how fame can destroy things and how you have to sometimes watch what you say and do.

But then there is the "gay Rights" agenda that had to be forced into there. Totally unnecessary and obviously a ploy by the author to get her point of view across. Even if Alice did make the quote about "doing what you want as long as you don't scare the horses" that is really pushing it...

AN OK read but too confusing about who it was written for.

Audrey's mom is president. But living in the White House is no fairy tale. With all the security, Audrey is not allowed to have friends over, which makes it hard to find friends. Then Audrey finds the diary of Alice Roosevelt and things get a bit more interesting. Alice also had a hard time in the WH, even a hundred years ago. Audrey reads about all of the ways that Alice had fun as First Daughter, and she cooks the goose a little bit herself.