Lorena A. HickokBesprekingen

EducatingParents.org rating: Approved
Under Review

very interesting and a good read

very interesting and a good read

I read this story as a girl and found it fascinating. Helen Keller lives in a dark work, unable to communicate with anyone because she was born blind and deaf. But then Anne Sullivan comes to teach her, and despite the fact that Helen has become a wild child, Miss Sullivan eventually teaches her to read, to write, and to live a full life. This is an amazing story!

L'histoire d'Helen Keller est celle d'une ouverture au monde et à la communication. Sourde et aveugle, Helen est enfermée dans un monde sans langage. Grâce à l'effort de sa professeur, elle découvrira la communication et pourra nommer le monde autour d'elle, via le toucher, le braille et l'alphabet tapé dans le creux de sa main.

Harry Hopkins was FDR's Federal Emergency Relief Administrator in 1933. Hopkins sent journalists around the country to write "reports" about the conditions they found. Hopkins sent Lorena Hickok traveling as a "confidential investigator" throughout the U.S. to report on "the state of tha nation."

Far from objective, Hockok saw the people of Tennessee, for example, as dirty, ignorant, and incapable of working their own land; they were "helpless victims" of nature who needed to be bailed out by Big Government.

This is from a letter from Hickok to Hopkins in 1934: "What to do with these people makes a nice little problem. Whether to move them off--and if so, where to put them--or, with careful and authoritative supervision they might eke out a living, leave them there and take a chance on their being absorbed in the industries that should be attracted down here by the cheap power furnished by TVA."

Hopkins had an agenda, and he used Hickok and others to meet that agenda: to prove that the country was in a "God-awful mess" and take the land from people in Appalachia in order to create dams for the Tennessee Valley Authority. If people were too "dirty and ignorant" to farm their own land, then it was no problem--it was even a good thing--for the government to take it from them.

Jim Powell in his book, FDR's Folly, has another take on the TVA, believing that it actually depressed the Tennessee economy. It's a complicated issue, with arguments for and against on both sides, but to say that Hickok was sent out to write "objective" reports is simply wrong.

One example that I know of personally: the TVA drowned the entire town of Butler, Tennessee. People whose families had lived in the area for generation after generation were given no choice but to sell their land to the government--at bargain (for the government) prices. They had to dig up the graves of their ancestors and move them to higher ground--or know that they would be left at the bottom of the new reservoir. I talked to a woman in the area in 2005 who was a child at the time. Speaking of her grandmother and others in the community, she said, "The government killed our old people." What the government did to these people was heartbreaking; Hickok's "reports" were in many cases simply telling the feds what they wanted to hear.

That being said, Lorena's letters to Harry Hopkins make fascinating reading.

Helen Keller was an amazing woman, and this book is great - especially for kids - to learn about her life. I learned how to finger spell because of this book as well.

This was the first biography I ever read of Helen Keller when I was a child. It has remained one of my favorites. It is written well, and easy for a young adult to understand, while maintaining the story of the remarkable Helen.