Marcello SimonettaBesprekingen

I started reading this but I realized that I really know nothing about Italian History and didn't have enough background to get alot from this. It's going to the work bookshelf for a while.

A light but compelling history of the effort, generally known as the Pazzi Conspiracy, to bring down the Medici in April 1478. Simonetta argues that the Duke of Urbino played a more important role in the conspiracy than others have claimed, after decoding a letter found in a private Italian archive. The argument is somewhat interesting but may perhaps be a bit overdrawn, and the narrative doesn't stand out very well. Readable, but unremarkable.½

Il libro si pone come biografia storica, ma meglio sarebbe definirlo romanzo storico d'intrattenimento. L'uso e l'abuso del discorso diretto da una parte e l'assordante tacere circa importanti vicende storiche accadute dall'altra vietano recisamente di catalogare l'opera come biografia storica. Giudizi recisi degli autori su personaggi storici, inoltre, lasciano il tempo che trovano, tanto più perchè emessi senza giustificazione alcuna. Nessun accenno invece sulla fonte dei soldi che Luciano impiegò generosamente per il mantenimento del suo elevato tenore di vita. Per finire, sono riscontrabili innumerevoli imprecisioni e sciatterie ed interi periodi letteralmente incomprensibili, sia in relazione al contesto, sia se presi isolatamente.½

This is a short, readable account of the so-called Pazzi conspiracy to kill Lorenzo de Medici and his brother, and to change the balance of power in the Italian peninsula.

The author, Marcello Simonetta, argues that the Duke of Urbino, Federico Montefeltro, was more heavily involved in the plot than previously thought. Simonetta bases his argument on a Montefeltro letter he found and then decoded.

Because the Duke of Urbino has long been suspected of being a part of the conspiracy, Mr. Simonetta's discovery, and therefore his book, is certainly not groundbreaking; but his book is an open window into the shifting, and often delicate, power struggle between the Italian states (and the pope), and into the personalities of the men who shaped Renaissance history: Lorenzo de Medici and Federico Montefeltro.

To bring these characters to life, the author republishes some of their letters; so we see first-hand their dilemmas and motivations.

The book also serves as a reminder that on one side of the Italian Renaissance is great art, great human achievement, but on the other side, are dark plots, conspiracies, power struggles and vendettas; so in a sense, the book offers a view of mankind as being divided between black and white.

Or maybe the book's perspective is that often there is no division between black and white, and that instead, much of the human experience is colored gray.

(As I read this book I couldn't help but see the origins of Machiavelli's political philosophy.)

It's quite remarkable, IMHO, that Lorenzo, through it all, retained many of his Renaissance ideals, so to me he is a symbol of a man having to overcome external obstacles and yet remain true to himself.

Or is he? The author briefly mentions that Lorenzo became a more repressive politician, but Mr. Simonetta doesn't explore how the assassination may have changed him.

(The most interesting history, I believe, is where we see how events change characters for better or worse.)

Also, I find this book lacking in that it tells only part of the Pazzi conspiracy: the roles and motivations of the Pazzis are hardly mentioned. Finally, Mr. Simonetta doesn't offer a unique or deep theory on the causes and forces of history, but then again, most historical authors don't.

Overall, this is an entertaining, well-written book that shines a somewhat narrow light on the history of Fifteenth century Italy.

For the serious student of the Italian Renaissance, the Medici Family, and the Pazzi Conspiracy, there is not much new information here. Try instead the excellent book The Pazzi Conspiracy: the Plot Against the Medici by Harold Acton.

I guess this is a "popular history" book, but even a non-historian like me would have liked a little more scholarship. Simonetta effectively builds to an anticlimax about halfway through, then spends the rest of this light volume watching the old men of Tuscany decay and die. I don't want to spoil it, in case anyone is interested, but the author's "discovery" doesn't really add much to our understanding of the murder of Giuliano de Medici.½

Ottima esposizione della scena politica del tardo '400 in Italia. Finalmente confermata con documenti la complicità del Montefeltro nella Congiura dei Pazzi

Marcello Simonetta's The Montefeltro Conspiracy revolves around the so-called Pazzi conspiracy of 1478; an attempt on the lives of Lorenzo de' Medici ("the Magnificent") and his brother Giuliano. Simonetta uses newly decoded documents to show the conspiracy was not driven by the Pazzi clan, but by the ambitious Duke of Urbino, Federico da Montefeltro. Given this newfound evidence, the author reconstructs the reasons behind the conspiracy and its effects on Renaissance Italy, which includes a new understanding of some of the greatest works of art.

While Simonetta's discovery is compelling and has important implications for our understanding of these Renaissance figures, the historical narrative is lacking. There is tremendous potential here, including Simonetta's personal connection to one of the players in the story. However, rather than filling out the narrative with historical details to enrich one's grasp of the times, his approach is spartan and rigid. I can't help think what an amazing story this would have been in another writer's hands.½

This book relates the factual story of the 1478 plot to kill Lorenzo and Giuliano DiMedici, and its aftermath. It gives excellent insight into the political machinations, papal politics, and intrigue of Renaissance Italy that gave rise to Machiavelli.
Since this was a real conspiracy, there are lots of characters to keep track of; but for those interested in the Italian Renaissance, it's definitely a good read. Simonetta brings history, art, and papal intrigue to life with great descriptions and a compelling narrative.