Stephen Drury Smith

Free All Along: The Robert Penn Warren Civil Rights Interviews collects extended versions of Warren's 1964 interviews with civil rights leaders of the time.

If you're familiar with the work the interviews were initially for, Who Speaks for the Negro?, you will appreciate these extended interviews that give a bit more glimpse into the individuals as well as their ideas. If you're not familiar with it, not a problem, this book stands on its own. It is also fascinating to go to the Vanderbilt website and visit the Who Speaks for the Negro? archive.

This book is valuable as both a type of history book in that it captures these leaders' opinions at that point and also as a book to help us move the fight forward by listening to what they thought in 1964 in light of what happened (or didn't happen) in the 55 years since. If you're interested in comparing thought across the spectrum of civil rights leaders this is a wonderful opportunity to make valid comparisons since, as any interviewer does when doing multiple interviews for one publication, Warren asked many of the same questions to each person.

The interviewees are well known to most people who either were alive during the 1960s and/or have made any effort to understand the Black freedom movement. There are a couple you may know by deed rather than name but you'll likely remember them all as you read. For those who don't, this is an excellent introduction to the thinking that has been the heart and soul of the movement, modified over the years but still largely valid today. That is a positive statement about the power and depth of the thinking but a sad statement about just how much further we still need to go over half a century later.

Reviewed from a copy made available by the publisher via NetGalley.… (meer)

In 1964, Robert Penn Warren was commissioned by “Look Magazine” to interview the leaders of the civil rights movement and that he did. Free All Along is an edited compilation of about a third of his interviews. Warren seemed to have a set of questions that preoccupied him. He wanted to know people’s opinions of the double consciousness from W.E.B. Du Bois’ “The Souls of Black Folk” though he called it a split psyche. He was fascinated by the movement’s nonviolence and asked about positive and negative nonviolence. Another frequent question was about the idea of revolution when there is no intention to destroy and replace, only to synthesize. Other revolutions change the power structure completely with regicide, imprisonment, or expulsion. African Americans sought a revolution of thought within the existing society, overthrowing racist ideology without replacing the government and constitution. He asks if such a revolution is possible.

He interviews all sorts of people. Some I have never heard of before and others are known to all, such as Malcolm X and Martin Luther King, Jr. It is the variety, the breadth of his interviews that make this such a valuable and fascinating series. The most interesting interviews, I thought, were with Robert Moses, Aaron Henry, and Wyatt Tee Walker. Robert Moses addressed that question of the split psyche by arguing that the struggle goes beyond racial justice to the humanitarian struggle and if that happens, the split disappears. I loved Aaron Henry’s way with words such as saying “Mississippi is not a mutation in America.” to argue that racism is not just in the South, not just in America, but in all of Western culture. He also said, “Because we realize that freedom is a peculiar kind of a commodity. You can only keep it by giving it away.” William Tee Walker expressed frustration with white liberals, “We are afflicted with worn-out white liberals who, fifteen years ago, could have been killed for what they were saying [against segregation]. But they’re saying the same things now that they were saying fifteen years ago, and as [American poet] James Russell Lowell has said, “Time makes ancient good uncouth .” We are at a different moment in history.” Reading the interviews, it is clear that the leadership was broad and deep with many strategic and brilliant thinkers.

I liked Free All Along very much. It introduced me to civil rights leaders who were new to me. the interviews were deep and philosophical. It’s only a third of the people interviewed, but quite likely the most interesting interviews. I found the archive of all the interviews that includes appendices and communications about the project and the eventual book he published “Who Speaks for the Negro?” The Robert Penn Warren of the book is much nicer than the one you find in the archives, the one who actually wrote that black people have rhythm and that King’s claims to nonviolence were sophistry since the demonstrations inspired violence by police and racists. Yup, he held black protesters responsible for white people beating them.

As Black History Month opens, this would be a good time to dive deeper into the wisdom of the civil rights movement and its leaders. It is obviously fascinating to me as it inspired me to go searching for more.

I received a copy of Free All Along: The Robert Penn Warren Civil Rights Interviews from the publisher through NetGalley.

Free All Along at The New Press
Stephen Drury Smith interview
Catherine Ellis

★★★★★
https://tonstantweaderreviews.wordpress.com/2019/02/01/free-all-along-edited-by-...… (meer)

Say It Plain: a Century of Great African American Speeches is a collection of landmark oratory spoken by black Americans whose goal was to urge America to live up to its promise of democratic justice. Although this anthology includes some of our nation’s most powerful, influential speeches, addresses, and legal arguments of the past sixty years, the chronological arrangement begins with Booker T. Washington’s speech to the Atlanta Cotton States and International Exposition delivered in 1895. Washington’s speech is immediately followed by a 1921 speech given by Marcus Garvey. The adjacent positioning of Garvey’s speech to Washington’s serves to compare Washington and Garvey’s shared view that the road to opportunity lies in effective use of American capitalism and to contrast Washington’s acceptance of slow progress to Garvey’s aggressive, demanding style. The collection moves on through the twentieth century and into the twenty-first century with the words of familiar leaders, but with some of their lesser known speeches and addresses, many here transcribed into print for the first time. Each selection is preceded by a short, informational introduction which serves as a history lesson or review depending on the reader’s personal knowledge and experience.

But Say It Plain is so much more than just another book of speeches by African American cultural and spiritual leaders and political figures. Indeed, Say It Plain is a book intended to be heard rather than read. The print form of the book accompanies two CDs which are actual, live recordings of the speechwriter’s original delivery, not actors’ voices or mere readings of the prepared text. The listener hears passion in the voices as the speakers sometimes stray from or augment the original versions.

Collecting recordings for this project was a difficult endeavor for the editors. Obviously recording equipment was in its infancy in the late 19th century as the scratchy sound of Booker T. Washington’s 1895 speech reminds us. Hearing this particular recording has launched this reviewer into another world of personal research on the history of recording technology. Although the search for recordings took the editors to libraries with vast African American collections such as the J. Fred MacDonald collection in the Chicago Vincent Voice Library at Michigan State University, some preserved recordings are in archives that are not readily accessible to the public. Some copyrights are owned by rich, private networks with permission fees too high for the budget of the project. And some family heirs holding copyrights to speeches simply denied requests to have their ancestors’ words included in the work.

Nevertheless, Say It Plain is an inspirational audio documentary of early American speeches not previously covered in other works. Say It Plain gives new life to some of history’s most powerful speeches for both young ears and old ears with no prior opportunity to hear the message the first time.

O, yes, I say it plain,

America never was America to me,

And yet I swear this oath-

America will be!

Langston Hughes

reviewed by Jen… (meer)