An Amish Christmas wish: Grace Fisher left the Amish community just after her baptism, frightened she'd missed out on exploring the English ways when her father had forbidden her to participate in her rumspringa. When she returns to the community just days before Christmas, her father turns her away. After running her car off the road in a blizzard, Grace ends up at he mercy of Ethan Bontranger, the man whose proposal she'd refused before leaving the community. Will the two of them be able to put the past behind them while trapped together in a blizzard?